Click here for search results

Inside Indonesia’s Mathematics Classrooms: A TIMSS (Trends in International Mathematics and Science Study) video study of teaching practices and student achievement

Available in: Bahasa (Indonesian)

This report increases understanding about teaching practices and effectiveness in Indonesia’s classrooms by providing rich before and after qualitative and quantitative empirical evidence to inform and guide future policy decisions. The objective of the report is to enable reflective discussion and analysis about teacher practices through the use of video case studies – with teachers, principals, supervisors and teacher training institutions.

KEY FINDINGS FROM THE REPORT

October 26, 2010

Lesson Structure

  • In Indonesia, more time is spent on non-math activities, practice, non-problem work and less on review and assessment.
  • Classes with good lesson plans and effective use of classroom time scored higher.

Content

  • Compared with other Trends in International Mathematics and Science Study (TIMSS) countries, Indonesia sets relatively few higher-order thinking problems.
  • Classes that used mathematical proofs scored higher.
  • In Indonesia, goal and summary statements were used by teachers frequently.

Instructional Practices

  • In Indonesia, teacher approach to maths is one correct approach to the solution.
  • Students speak much less than teacher and use short responses when answering questions.
  • Classes with more student involvement tended to score higher.
  • Student problem solving often involves simple repetition of teacher examples

    RECOMMENDATIONS
    • Professional Development of Mathematics Teachers

      • Promotion of Ministry of Education (MONE)’s policy of Active Learning, which is supported by findings that more active student participation is associated with higher test scores .
      • Review training in pre-service, in-service, Musyawarah Guru Mata Pelajaran (MGMP) in light of findings, which indicate need to:
        • Orient problem solving to encourage higher order thinking, use of applications and proofs, making connections and multiple solutions.
        • Ensure effective and efficient use of class time.
        • Increase use of activities such as review and assessment which currently receive little time.
        • Encourage student engagement, participation and active learning.
        • Effectively use resources (projector, textbooks, math materials) in learning.
        • Incorporate video techniques into MGMP activities for reflective self and peer evaluation.
      • Leverage videos for examples of good and innovative practices and develop a teaching practices archive.
    • Educational System Support (Ministry of Education - MONE & Ministry of Religious Affair - MORA)
      • Review current policies of combining two periods of math and use of calculators in class.
      • Supervision by mathematics supervisors through on-the-spot training using communicative supervision so that teachers and principals receive feedback useful for improving the quality of teaching.
      • Monitoring by head teacher of classroom teachers based on feedback provided by supervisors.
      • Extending the video study:
        • Conducting similar video studies in other topics such as science and literacy.
        • Continuing the mathematics video study beyond 2011 to allow for long-term trending.
        • Incorporating teacher assessment and pre- and post- testing of students to measure gains
    Download:
    English Version
    Inside Indonesia’s Mathematics Classrooms: A TIMSS video study of teaching practices and student achievement

    World Bank Program on Education in Indonesia


    For journalists

    Contact:
    In Jakarta:
    Gedisiri Suhartono
    (62-21) 5299-3114
    gsuhartono1@worldbank.org




    Permanent URL for this page: http://go.worldbank.org/JLX6NA8Y20