CPAR - Attachment 2

Each CPAR will be different and reflect the scope and content as agreed in the approved Initiating Concept Memorandum (ICM). The following provides guidelines on format and content based on a "standardized model" that should be used where and when applicable.

I. Executive Summary

1.      Introductory Remarks
2.      Summary of Critical Findings and Brief Analysis
3.      Outline of Recommended Action Plan

II. Report

A. Preface:

1.      Date and Basis for Report
2.      Acknowledgments
3.      Government Participating Organizations
4.      Other Co-Sponsors/Contributors
5.      World Bank Team

           B. Background:

1.      Relevant Country Information (may be summarized from ICM)
2.      Bank Portfolio in Country (actual and planned)
3.      Brief Discussion on Extent of Government Participation in CPAR

C. Discussion and analysis of Findings: (customized to scope of the CPAR as defined in the ICM)

Public Sector

1. Legal and Regulatory Framework
2. Procedures and Practices
3. Organization and Resources
4. Audit and Anti-Corruption Measures
5. Public Sector Management Performance
6. Performance on Bank-Financed Projects
7. General Risk Assessment
8. Recommended Supervision Plan and Identification of Unacceptable Practices for use in Bank-Financed Projects

Private Sector

1.      Competitiveness and Participation of Private Sector in Public Procurement
2.      Performance on Public Procurement Contracts (quality, timeliness, disputes)
3.      Commercial Practices as they Relate to Public Procurement System

D. Recommended Action Plan:

1. Sequenced Actions Summarized by Major Categories
2. Identification of Measures to be Taken by Government/Private Sector
3. Identification of Measures to be Taken by Bank and other Donors/Organizations
4. Technical Assistance
5. Timetable
6. Potential Sources of Financing
7. Monitoring and Follow-up Plans

III. Attachments and Annexes

1.      Background and Supporting Material for the Team's Findings

2.      Listing of Laws/Regulations, etc.

3.      Other Relevant Information such as Special Studies, Statistical Data, etc.